A proposed $1.1 million covered event space for Feilding’s Manchester Square is drawing growing public reaction, with many residents questioning whether it’s the right use of ratepayer money.
The latest quantity surveyor estimate puts the project at $1.1 million, although the final cost has not yet been confirmed. Some residents are also concerned the price could increase, pointing to other council projects around New Zealand that have gone over budget.
Concept designs released by the Manawatū District Council show a modern covered event space in the Manchester Square Brick Quadrant, home to the weekly Feilding Farmers’ Market and other community events. Supporters say it would make the space more practical year-round, while critics believe the design doesn’t fit the town centre’s historic Edwardian character.
Recent coverage and public commentary across multiple news platforms have raised questions about the council’s decision to appoint a Wellington architect rather than a local designer, prompting debate among members of the Feilding community.
Some observers have characterised the proposal as “completely out of character” with the surrounding streetscape, while also raising concerns about constructing a large timber structure in a public space. Concerns raised have included potential challenges around fire regulations, insurance costs, maintenance requirements, moisture damage, vandalism, and the ongoing costs associated with cleaning and upkeep.
Mayor Michael Ford has backed the proposal, saying the Town Centre Vitality Project is “a topic close to my heart”. He described parts of the town centre as “a bit shabby” and said the project would add vibrancy, support economic growth and provide much-needed weather protection for the farmers’ market. He also believes the structure would create a “wow factor” for the town centre.
Feilding Town Centre Refresh Committee chair Cr Raewyn Loader said the project has been planned for years and isn’t new.
“Funding has already been allocated for 10 years from 2024 to 2034. So it’s not about introducing extra rates, it’s funding that has already been approved,” she said in a council video.
Loader also described the town centre as “our community yard”, saying investment in public spaces is an investment in the future of the community.
Despite those assurances, criticism has continued across social media. While Facebook comments show strong public opinion, they are not included in the council’s consultation feedback unless people also make a submission through the consultation process.
The biggest concerns raised by residents include the projects cost, the risk of graffiti and vandalism, ongoing maintenance, and whether the funding would be better spent reducing council debt, easing pressure on rates, improving CCTV and security, upgrading sports facilities or supporting other community priorities. Others have questioned whether the project is needed at all, arguing Manchester Square’s open-air layout is already one of Feilding’s defining features.
The council’s public consultation on the proposal is now open, giving residents the opportunity to formally support, oppose, or suggest changes to the project. While debate continues both online and in the community, only submissions received through the official consultation process will be considered as part of the council’s decision-making. Residents wishing to have their views taken into account are encouraged to make a submission before the consultation closes.